• RSS Feeds
  • Login
  • Register
  • Warlord Games 28 mm Plastic Roman Legionnaires

    Review
    By Bob Barnetson

    In May 2008, Warlord Games will release its new line of hard-plastic 28 mm Roman Imperial Legionnaires. Following shortly will be some 28 mm Celts to pit against them. Each boxed set of Legionnaires contains 30 multi-part figures and costs £17. Warlord Games expects the figures to be released during the week of May 12.

    Initial Impressions
    I was pleasantly surprised to receive the contents of an entire box (three sprues: one command and two legionnaire) ahead of their release. These figures did not come with their normal box or the water-slide shield transfers, but that does not diminish how impressive they are.

    The figures are cast in a grey plastic on sprues measuring five by eight inches. As I unwrapped them, they reminded me of plastic 1:72-figures, not the bags of shiny 28 mm historical I normally buy. But the similarity to 1:72-plastic figures was short-lived. These plastics are crisply cast, not at all bendy, and there is very little flash.

    Legionnaires close-up
    Click to enlarge

    The Sprues
    Warlord’s figures come on two different sprues. The first sprue (two to a box) contains 10 legionnaires in three different poses. You can customize each legionnaire by gluing the separate head and weapon arm (with molded weapon) on at different angles. The distinctive rectangular shields (scutum) must also be individually attached. For the 10 legionnaires, there are 12 arms to choose from: eight with pilum (spear) and four with gladius (short-swords). There are also 10 heads, two spare helmets, 2 spare pila, two round shields, and a head with what is perhaps a cavalry helmet.

    Legionnaire sprue
    Click to enlarge

    The command sprue (one to a box) contains seven legionnaire and three command figures. The command figures include a centurion, a standard bearer and a musician (signifer and cornicern). The armour of the command figures is distinctive, as is the head dress. Two heads have pelts attached and dangling down the figures’ backs and the centurion head has the distinctive helmet, with horse-hair crest running across the top of the helmet, from ear to ear. The centurion can be built holding either a gladius or a wooden rod.

    Command sprue
    Click to enlarge

    Sculpting and Posing
    The sculpting is of high quality. The figures have a build somewhere between the very thin frames of most 1:72-scale sculpts and the beefy builds common in 28 mm metals. All told, they have a realistic look with enough musculature on the exposed arms and calves to warrant a bit of highlighting.

    There appear to be three different heads (mouth open, mouth snarling, mouth grimacing). The variation is nice. The typical trooper helmet includes cheek protectors, which leave the ears exposed. There is only a hint of an ear visible on the models, making it look like the cheek plate joins the helmet, thereby covering the ears. I expect this reflects a limitation in casting technology, rather than an oversight. This is a very minor criticism but does create some painting challenges. Without a molded edge, I will have to eyeball the ear and try to create some definition there with paint.

    Command sprue close-up
    Click to enlarge

    The detail on the figures is well rendered. The bottoms of the tunics have enough ripples to almost look pleated. This is quite different from many metal sculpts where the ripples are fewer and gentler. This type of detail ought to take highlighting well. Some of the tunics are a bit short in the back <ahem> but fortunately the sculptor has not treated us to any backsides.

    Short shorts

    The legionnaires wear the lorica segmentata (segmented armour) that is commonly seen in the movies. It is well rendered, with enough exaggeration of its depth that a wash or use of the magic dip ought to make it really stand out.

    Casting
    The figures come with very little flash. The bases have a faint mould line that will need to be filed off or puttied over. The figures also have a faint mould line down their sides that must be removed. This is fairly easy to address, but the mould line on the shoulders will require some work. It runs perpendicular to the grain of the lorica segmentata, meaning each shoulder has five separate surfaces to scrape (plus the flesh on the arm). A misstep with a knife here will be most noticeable, so clean up will be a bit time consuming.

    Shoulder mould line

    Assembly
    For this review, I assembled the centurion figure and one of the legionnaires. Each figure took approximately 5 minutes to cut out, de-flash, dry fit and glue. There were no assembly problems with these figures. Each piece fit precisely and, had I wanted to, I could have altered the arm and head positions to introduce additional diversity in the poses.

    Upon assembly, each figure was 28 mm tall (top of base to top of head). When measuring the centurion, I excluded the horse-hair crest on the centurion’s helmet from the measurement. The overall look is quite lovely.

    Assembled Centurion Assembled Legionnaire
    Click to enlarge

    Comments
    Frankly, these are spectacular figures. They put most of the currently available plastics in 1:72- and 1:32-scale to shame in their detail (excepting some Italeri and Clash of Arms releases). And they should give even the most metal-loving grognard an alternative to lead. That said, I have some reservations.

    Centurion I’m primarily a historical gamer. The amount of assembly these figures entail is a bit daunting. I know most GW gamers will be used to this work, but most historical 28 mm metals normally require only some flash removal and a shield (and sometimes weapon) be glued on. Warlord’s figures must be cut from the sprue, deflashed, fitted, and then require at least three pieces glued on.

    To be fair, gluing hard plastic is much easier than gluing metal. And this arrangement does allow me to customize each figure. This advantage is not, however, all that appealing as (at least to me) part of the gestalt of many historical periods (including ancients and Napoleonics) is seeing large armies of identical figures ranked up together. I may be in the minority on that point, however, and perhaps not Warlord’s primary target with these figures. I expect that most gamers will like the easy customization.

    Of course, an important question is how well do Warlord’s figures fit in with existing metal lines. These figures appear to be 28 mm from top of base to top of head. My impression is that they should fit in with the 28 mm Foundry figures quite well. The Warlord shields are a bit smaller than the Foundry ones (but this won’t be noticeable on the table) but otherwise they should be compatible. The Warlord figures will be too big to go well with more traditional 25mm figures such as RaFM and Irregular.

    I wonder whether the additional granularity of the details on the Warlord figures won’t be jarring when set against the lesser detail typically found on metal figures? Generally, the Warlord figures have more and finer detail than metals. This may be less of a problem as Warlord’s line expands and it is possible to put together most of a Warhammer Ancient Battles army with only their figures.

    Conclusion
    The release of hard-plastic historical figures is a notable event and a significant investment on the part of Warlord Games. I expect the costs of making injection moulds involved will limit (at least initially) the periods that Warlord and other manufacturers will tackle. This has the advantage of focusing manufacturers’ attention on a single period long enough to provide fairly thorough coverage.

    Warlord has already announced that Celtic warriors will be forthcoming. They have also announced plans for plastic Praetorian Guard and Veteran Legionnaire boxes are also promised. Other figures in metal will also be available, including eastern archers.

    The price of these figures, their compatibility with widely played rule sets (e.g., Warhammer Ancient Battles) and the ease with which hard-plastic figures can be put together ought to make them attractive to many gamers.

    Pros

    • Highly detailed sculpts.
    • Competitively priced versus metals.
    • Plastic figures are easy to assemble.

    Cons

    • Assembly might turn off some gamers.

    13 Responses to “Warlord Games 28 mm Plastic Roman Legionnaires”


    Quirkworthy says:

    Personally, seeing large armies of identical figures makes me wonder why the owner bothered. I can never understand why anyone would go through the expense and effort to make something so lifeless. Even the most drilled of humans in a unit don’t look identical, and the ability to customise models as you assemble them to make them look like they’ve got a bit of life to them is, for me at least, important. I’m very pleased to see this new series of products and will be adding them to my collection when I can get hold of them.

    Of course everyone’s got their own view, but for those folk that don’t like assembly and want the army to look identical there’s loads of alternatives already out there.

    I think the posability is one of the USPs for Warlord here, and gawd bless ‘em for it :o)


    Zac says:

    USP?


    Grant says:

    Unique Selling Point?


    Quirkworthy says:

    Just so.

    Any business idea needs a USP (at least, that’s what I was taught and that’s what banks will often look for). Why are you different, why will people buy your product and not Brand X? Because of your Unique Selling Point.

    A USP could be almost anything, but here it’s posability (I think) together with price compared to other 28mms. Price on its own isn’t unique as soft plastics probably still win there.

    Anyway, just my 2c.


    altfritz says:

    Quickworthy - you’re fooling yourself if you think multi-part figures can make an army of 28mm figures look more real than the traditional matal figures. In case you hadn’t noticed people come in a wide range of heights and builds that very few manufacturers seek to represent. The only one - in fact - that I can think of was the Wargames Foundry with their Street Violence and Viking ranges which had at least some variety in body types.


    Zac says:

    A USP could be almost anything, but here it’s posability (I think) together with price compared to other 28mms.

    I see what you mean now. Thanks

    As much as these are aimed at mass combat gamers I think that there is probably a fairly big market for people that do ancient skirmish gaming to really go to town with these and do some conversions.


    bork da basher says:

    at the end of the day they are plastic and there is no easier substance to convert when it comes to models. the variation isnt great i agree, especially when there is massed units of them. it can all look very samey very quickly. however the option is there to convert. the models are not that detailed that resculpting parts even for a reletive beginner would be that much of a challenge. a few respositioned arms, heads etc etc would make the differance. personnally i think they look great but im waiting for the celts to be released personnally.


    briguy says:

    Very interesting and timely review, thanks Bob. This is not a scale that holds interest for me, but I do think that companies like Warlords may be able to begin bringing plastics technology to be more widespread. I personally love the convertability of plastics, so I’m curious to see where else this may spread to.


    gavroche says:

    Funny how historical gamers seem to dislike that the figures are multipart. Personally that’s one of the things I really like about Warlords new range. Even though I would’ve liked to see more parts (separate bases, separate torso’s & lower bodies, 2 separate arms…). I also love the material, plastic is so much more convenient to work with than metal. And all the detail will make them easy to drybrush & dip, which should be handy for those who want to put a half-decently painted army on the table quickly.

    In themselves, the romans hold zero interest for me since I’m not a historical gamer, but I’m looking forward to the celts, which look useful as fantasy chaos barbarian conversion material.


    altfritz says:

    I don’t mind multi-part, but the main problem is always: how do they hide the seamlines. GW space marines have convenient shoulder plates to disguise the join. The celts will not. It will be interesting to see how noticeable the join it.


    gavroche says:

    You can always smooth over joints using some sort of filler (putty, modelling paste…). Just as with metal miniatures.


    Dorb says:

    Great review. Wonder how these will match up with the Wargames Factory troops when they finally get released? Should give you lots of options and different looks in the battle line. I think they are both from different time periods in the Roman empire.


    Bob says:

    The big differences between WG and WF will be shield shape (oval republicans versus rectangular imperials) and armour (segmented imperials versus mailed republicans). If you are not too picky, there’s nothing to stop you from mixing and matching. Depending on what is released as auxiliary troops, you ought to be able to mix and match those fair well.


    Leave a Reply

    You must be logged in to post a comment.